6 min read
B04

Builders · No. 09

Running to Stay in Place

In a world where everyone is improving, getting better is the price of standing still. Winning means changing the race.

· · 6 min · 1,461 words

In short

  • In Through the Looking-Glass, the Red Queen tells Alice that it takes all the running you can do to keep in the same place.
  • Biologist Leigh Van Valen used this image in 1973 to describe how species must keep adapting because their competitors keep adapting too.
  • In competitive markets, improvements that everyone makes cancel out, so getting better often only keeps you level.
  • Standing still in a moving field is the same as falling behind.
  • The escape is not to run faster but to change the race, by competing on a dimension your rivals are not optimising.

In Lewis Carroll's Through the Looking-Glass, published in 1871, Alice finds herself running hand in hand with the Red Queen. They run faster and faster, so fast that Alice can barely breathe. When they finally stop, she looks around and is astonished. They are under the same tree where they started.

In her country, Alice says, if you ran that fast for that long you would generally get somewhere else.

The Queen calls that a slow sort of country. Here, she explains, it takes all the running you can do to keep in the same place. If you want to get somewhere else, you must run at least twice as fast.

It reads like a joke from a children's book. It turned out to be one of the most precise descriptions of competition ever written.

A biologist's law

A century later, an evolutionary biologist named Leigh Van Valen was studying the fossil record. He noticed something odd. Within many groups of animals, the chance that a given family would go extinct did not seem to drop much the longer it had survived. An old, well established group was not obviously safer than a young one.

That was strange. You would expect a lineage that had survived millions of years to be well adapted and hard to kill. Why wasn't it?

In 1973, Van Valen proposed an answer in a paper called "A New Evolutionary Law," and he named his idea after Carroll's Queen. A species does not live in a fixed world. It lives among predators, prey, parasites and competitors, and all of them are evolving too. Every improvement one species makes worsens the environment for the others, which then adapt in return.

So no species ever gets to rest. Being well adapted is a race you keep running, against opponents who never stop.

The classic picture is the cheetah and the gazelle. Over long stretches of time, faster predators favour faster prey, and faster prey favour faster predators. Both get better. Neither gets ahead. The hunt stays roughly as hard as it always was.

No species ever gets to rest. Neither does any company.

The same race in business

Once you see the Red Queen, you see her everywhere.

Think about the features in a category of software. One company adds a new capability. Customers like it. Within a year, every serious competitor has built the same thing. The first company did get better. Its customers are better off. But its position relative to rivals is exactly where it began.

Or think about advertising. If one brand raises its spending, it may win attention for a while. Then the others raise theirs. Now everyone is spending more and nobody is more visible than before. The real winner is whoever sells the ads.

The same happens with prices, with speed of delivery, with free returns, with nicer offices to attract engineers. Each move makes sense on its own. Together they cancel out. The whole industry runs harder and stays under the same tree.

This is uncomfortable, because most advice about success is really advice about running faster. Work harder, ship more, optimise every metric. In a Red Queen market, that advice is necessary just to survive. It is not enough to win.

Standing still is falling behind

The flip side is just as important. If running only keeps you in place, then stopping moves you backward.

There is a well known story from Kodak. In 1975, one of its own engineers, Steven Sasson, built an early digital camera. Kodak had a head start on the technology that would eventually replace its core business. But film was enormously profitable, and the company was slow to push hard in the new direction. The world kept running. Kodak, in the ways that mattered, slowed down. It filed for bankruptcy protection in 2012.

The lesson people usually draw is that Kodak missed the future. The Red Queen lesson is sharper. Kodak did not need to make a catastrophic mistake to fall behind. It only needed to treat its position as safe in a world that was not standing still.

The same is true for you as a person. Skills that were valuable five years ago may be ordinary today, not because you got worse but because the field moved. If you have stopped learning, you have not paused. You are sliding back, slowly enough that you might not notice until it is late.

When the tools are free for everyone

There is a version of this race happening right now, and you are probably in it.

AI tools let a single person write, code, design and research far faster than a few years ago. If you are the only one using them, that is a real advantage. You ship in a week what used to take a month.

But you are not the only one. The same tools are available to your competitors, often at the same price, on the same day. When everyone gets faster, the speed stops being an edge. It becomes the new floor. Customers simply start expecting the faster version, and the work that felt impressive last year becomes ordinary.

This is the Red Queen in its purest form. Any advantage that can be bought off the shelf will soon be owned by everyone. It still matters, because the people who refuse to adopt it will fall behind. But it will not set you apart for long.

So the useful question about any new tool goes beyond how much faster it makes you. Ask what it lets you do that your rivals, holding the very same tool, will not think to do. The answer to that usually comes from something they cannot buy: your taste, your customers, your knowledge of a specific problem.

How to change the race

If running faster only keeps you level, how does anyone ever get ahead?

The Queen gives one answer: run twice as fast. Sometimes that is possible. A team with a real edge in talent, speed or capital can pull away for a while. But it is expensive, and your rivals are trying to do the same.

The better answer is to stop running the race everyone else is running.

Nintendo is a good example. For years, the competition in video game consoles was mostly about raw power: better graphics, faster chips. Nintendo, with the Wii in 2006, chose not to win that race. It built a less powerful machine with motion controls and games that families and people who had never played before could enjoy. It was competing on a different dimension, and for a while its rivals' horsepower barely mattered.

That is the core move. Find the axis where everyone is optimising, and ask what customers want that nobody is competing on. In their book Blue Ocean Strategy, W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne describe this as leaving the crowded red ocean, where rivals fight over the same customers, for open water where competition is irrelevant for a time.

A few questions help you look for a new race:

  1. What does every competitor measure themselves on? That is the race. Assume you cannot win it cheaply.
  2. Who is being ignored? Often it is the customers considered too small, too new or too unprofitable by the leaders.
  3. What could you remove? Rivals keep adding features to keep up with each other. Sometimes the opening is a simpler product that does less.
  4. What do you have that others cannot copy quickly? A relationship, a location, a dataset, a culture. Races built on those are harder to join.

The trap of the new race

There is a catch. A new race does not stay new.

If your different approach works, others will notice and follow. Your open water fills up. Soon you are running a fresh Red Queen race in a market you created. That is what success looks like, and it means you have to keep finding the next edge.

This is why the best builders seem restless. They understand that any advantage is a lead, not a place to live. You will have to keep moving either way. What matters is whether you are moving in the same direction as everyone else.

Any advantage is a lead, not a place to live.

Running with intent

There is something almost reassuring about the Red Queen once you accept her. If everyone has to run, then the effort is simply the cost of being in a living field rather than a dead one.

So keep running. Learn, improve and ship, because standing still is falling behind.

But every so often, stop and look at where you are. If you are still under the same tree, and everyone around you is panting just as hard, you have your answer. More speed will not help.

Find a different road.

Further reading

  • Through the Looking-Glass — Lewis Carroll
  • The Red Queen — Matt Ridley
  • Blue Ocean Strategy — W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne

More from the shelf

B05 · Builders · 6 minThe Beauty of Boring BusinessesThe companies nobody brags about at dinner are often the ones quietly paying for the dinner. B06 · Builders · 6 minThe Ten-Person CompanyInstagram sold for a billion dollars with 13 people. AI is about to make that look crowded. N04 · Mind · 7 minThe Quiet ExponentThe most powerful force in your life feels like nothing for years, and then it feels like everything.

See the whole library →