7 min read
N05

Mind · No. 16

Where Your Hours Go

Information was never the scarce thing. Your attention is, and an entire industry is built to harvest it.

· · 7 min · 1,522 words

In short

  • Herbert Simon argued in 1971 that a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention, which makes attention the real scarce resource.
  • Free products that earn money from engagement are designed to capture as much of your attention as possible, and they are very good at it.
  • What you pay attention to becomes your experience, and over years it becomes your character.
  • Willpower loses to design, so the reliable fix is to change your environment and defaults rather than try harder.
  • The goal is not less technology but attention that you spend on purpose.

In 1971, an economist and computer scientist named Herbert Simon published a paper about how organisations should be designed in a world flooded with information. Simon would later win a Nobel Prize in economics. Most of the paper was the kind of thing you would expect. One idea was not.

He pointed out that information consumes something. It consumes the attention of the people who receive it. So, he said, a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention.

That was more than fifty years ago. There was no internet as you know it, no smartphone, no feed. Simon was thinking about memos and reports and the growing piles of paper on a manager's desk. He still saw the shape of the whole thing.

Today you carry the flood in your pocket. And the line he wrote is the most useful sentence I know for understanding where your hours go.

The scarce thing changed

For most of history, information was expensive. Books were copied by hand. News travelled at the speed of a horse or a ship. A merchant in the Gulf might wait weeks to learn what pearls were fetching in Bombay. If you knew something others did not, you had an edge.

So people built their habits around getting more information. Read more, collect more, subscribe to more. That instinct made sense when information was rare.

It does not make sense now. You could not read everything published on a single topic in a single day if you gave it your whole life. Information is no longer the bottleneck. You are.

Simon's point was economic. When something becomes abundant, its value collapses, and the value moves to whatever is still scarce. When information became effectively free, the scarce thing became the human attention needed to take it in.

And whatever is scarce, someone will try to own.

Who is paying for the free things

Most of the apps on your phone cost you nothing. That should make you curious.

A large share of the consumer internet runs on a simple model. You get the product free. Advertisers pay to reach you. The more time you spend inside the product, the more ads it can show, and the more it learns about what you will click. Engagement is the number that matters, so engagement is the number that gets optimised.

None of this requires anyone to be evil. It only requires thousands of smart, well-paid people running experiments every day on what makes you stay a little longer. A button colour here, a notification timing there, a new way to sort the feed. Each change is small. Each one is tested. The ones that keep you looking survive.

Run that process for a decade and you get products that are extraordinarily good at holding attention. Not because any single designer wanted to trap you, but because the system rewards whatever works, and what works is whatever you find hard to put down.

The engineer Aza Raskin, who designed infinite scroll, has spoken publicly about regretting how it came to be used. His idea removed a natural stopping point. When there is no bottom of the page, there is no moment where you ask yourself whether you want to keep going.

That is the quiet trick of the whole industry. It removes the moments where you would have decided.

Whoever controls your defaults controls most of your day.

What attention actually is

It is tempting to treat attention as a productivity problem. You want to focus better so you can get more done. That is part of it, but it undersells the stakes.

In 1890, the psychologist William James wrote that his experience was what he agreed to attend to. Think about that for a moment. Of everything happening around you, you only live through the part you notice. The rest might as well not exist.

So your attention is not just a tool for work. It is the raw material of your life. What you look at, day after day, becomes what you think about. What you think about becomes what you care about. Over enough years, it becomes who you are.

This is why a lost afternoon to a feed feels worse than a lost afternoon to a nap. The nap gave you rest. The feed took the afternoon and filled it with things you did not choose and will not remember.

Oliver Burkeman points out that if you live to eighty, you get roughly four thousand weeks. That number is small enough to count. It is worth asking how many of them you want to spend looking at things picked by an algorithm trained to keep you scrolling.

Why trying harder does not work

The usual advice is discipline. Put the phone down. Be stronger.

That advice is fighting the wrong battle. On one side you have your willpower, which is tired by the evening and easily bargained with. On the other side you have products tuned by enormous teams over years to beat exactly that willpower. It is not a fair fight, and you should stop expecting to win it head on.

The better approach is to change the terrain. People who protect their attention well tend not to be the ones with superhuman self control. They are the ones who arranged their lives so that they rarely need it.

Some changes that work, because they act on your environment instead of your resolve:

  • Turn off almost every notification. Keep only the ones from real people who need you. Everything else can wait until you choose to look.
  • Move the worst apps off your home screen, or delete them and use the web version, which is usually clumsier. A few seconds of friction is often enough to break the reflex.
  • Decide what you will read before you open anything. Going in with a question is very different from going in to see what is there.
  • Give your phone a place to sleep that is not your bedroom. The first and last hour of the day set the tone for everything between.
  • Batch the shallow stuff. Messages and email in a couple of windows a day, not a constant drip.

None of these is dramatic. Together, they hand the defaults back to you.

Deep work is the reward

Cal Newport makes a strong case that the ability to focus without distraction on hard things is becoming both rarer and more valuable at the same time. Rarer, because the environment works against it. More valuable, because the problems worth solving need long stretches of uninterrupted thought.

If you build things, you know the feeling. A real idea rarely arrives in a five minute gap between notifications. It arrives in the third hour of wrestling with something, when the surface noise has finally cleared. Every interruption pushes you back to the start of that climb.

When you learn to hold your attention for hours at a time, you gain more than efficiency. You get access to a kind of thinking most people around you have quietly lost.

That is a real advantage. It might be one of the last cheap ones left.

Attention as respect

There is a social side to this too.

In the Gulf, the majlis has always been a place where people sit together and talk for a long time. Nobody is in a hurry. The point of the gathering is the gathering. When someone speaks, you listen. That patience is a form of respect.

A phone on the table changes that, even when it is face down. Part of your mind is waiting for it. The person in front of you can feel it.

Giving someone your full attention has become one of the most generous things you can do, exactly because it has become so rare. Your parents, your friends, the people you work with: they all know the difference between having your presence and having your half presence.

Attention is the one gift you cannot fake for long.

Owning it

None of this means you should throw away your phone or move to a cabin. Technology is how you learn, build, and stay close to people far away. The trouble starts when other people decide how you use them.

Owning your attention starts with a simple shift. Stop treating it as something that happens to you, and start treating it as something you spend. Every hour has a destination. The question is only whether you picked it.

At the end of most days, you can ask one honest question. Where did my hours go? If the answer is a list of things you chose, the day was yours. If the answer is a blur you cannot quite reconstruct, someone else had it.

Simon saw it coming before any of us had the devices to prove him right. Information will keep getting cheaper. More of it will be generated, more of it will be aimed at you, more of it will be very good at catching your eye.

Your attention will not get any more plentiful. You get the same hours every day as everyone who has ever lived.

Spend them like they are the scarcest thing you own. They are.

Further reading

  • Four Thousand Weeks — Oliver Burkeman
  • Deep Work — Cal Newport
  • Stolen Focus — Johann Hari

More from the shelf

N02 · Mind · 7 minBet on Old ThingsThe best predictor of how long something will last is how long it has already lasted. N03 · Mind · 6 minThe Planes That Didn't Come BackThe most important evidence is usually the evidence that never made it home. O05 · Origins · 6 minThe Man Who Looked at LightA thousand years ago in Cairo, Ibn al-Haytham sat in a dark room and decided not to believe anything he could not test.

See the whole library →