6 min read
N07

Mind · No. 27

Invert, Always Invert

Charlie Munger once gave a graduation speech on how to be miserable. It is still the best advice he ever gave.

· · 6 min · 1,430 words

In short

  • Inversion means approaching a problem from the opposite end, asking how to fail and then steering clear of those paths.
  • Charlie Munger borrowed the habit from the mathematician Carl Jacobi and applied it to investing, business and life.
  • A pre-mortem asks a team to imagine a project has already failed and explain why, which surfaces risks people would otherwise keep quiet about.
  • The aviation checklist grew out of studying a crash, showing how organisations can turn failure into rules.
  • Inversion is better at preventing disasters than at producing greatness, so it works best paired with ambition.

In 1986, Charlie Munger stood up to speak at a high school graduation in Los Angeles. Graduation speeches usually tell young people how to succeed. Munger, who was then in his sixties and already one of the most successful investors in America, told them how to be miserable.

He was building on an earlier speech at the same school by the television host Johnny Carson, who had offered his own prescriptions for a guaranteed miserable life: taking chemicals to alter your mood or perception, envy and resentment. Munger added a few of his own.

Be unreliable. Do not faithfully do what you said you would do.

Learn everything you can from your own personal experience, and as little as possible from the experience of others, living or dead.

When life hits you with a serious setback, go down and stay down.

It sounds like a comedy routine, and the audience surely laughed. But the speech was a demonstration of a thinking tool Munger used for his whole career. He even named its source: a nineteenth-century German mathematician called Carl Jacobi, who liked to say that you must always invert.

Invert, always invert.

Thinking backwards

Jacobi was talking about mathematics. Many problems that are hard to solve forwards become much easier when you turn them around: assume the opposite, work from the answer back to the question, or solve the inverse of the problem instead.

You already know this from childhood puzzles. A maze on the back of a cereal box can be hard to solve from the entrance, with branches everywhere. Start from the exit and trace backwards, and the path often appears almost at once. The mathematician George Pólya listed working backwards as a core strategy in his classic book How to Solve It, published in 1945.

Munger's insight was that this does not only work for equations. It works for careers, companies and lives.

Instead of asking "How do I build a great company?", ask "What would reliably destroy a company like mine?" Instead of "How do I have a good marriage?", ask "What do people do that ruins marriages?" Instead of "How do I become a good investor?", ask "How do most investors lose money?"

Then avoid those things.

Munger liked to quote a line, which he attributed to a rustic, that sums it up: all I want to know is where I'm going to die, so I'll never go there.

All I want to know is where I'm going to die, so I'll never go there.

Why backwards works

There is something odd about this. Why should the reverse question be easier than the direct one?

One reason is that success is usually vague and failure is usually specific. Ask a team how to make a product great and you get abstractions: better design, more user focus, faster shipping. Ask them how the product could die and you get concrete answers: the onboarding is confusing, the biggest customer is unhappy, the main engineer is burning out, a competitor just cut prices. Specific problems are things you can act on.

Another reason is that avoiding stupidity compounds. Munger observed that he and Warren Buffett had gained a great deal over the years simply by trying to be consistently not stupid, rather than trying to be very intelligent. Brilliant moves are rare and hard to plan. Avoidable disasters are common and easy to spot once you look for them. If you just stop making the big, obvious mistakes, you are already ahead of most people.

And a third reason is psychological. When we plan forwards, we are emotionally invested in the plan working. We look for reasons it will succeed. Inversion gives us permission to look at the ugly possibilities without feeling disloyal to the plan.

The pre-mortem

That last point is the idea behind one of the most useful meeting formats ever invented.

The psychologist Gary Klein called it the pre-mortem. A post-mortem happens after something has died, to work out why. A pre-mortem happens before you start.

It goes like this. The team has agreed on a plan. Before anyone begins, the leader says: imagine it is a year from now. We did the project. It failed, badly. Take a few minutes and write down every reason you think it failed.

Something remarkable happens. People who would never say "I think this plan is weak" in a normal meeting will happily write "it failed because the deadline was unrealistic" or "it failed because we never checked whether customers wanted this." The exercise turns doubt from disloyalty into a contribution. Klein drew on earlier research suggesting that imagining an event has already happened helps people come up with more reasons to explain it.

You end up with a list of the most likely ways your plan will die, written by the people closest to it. You can then fix the weakest points before they break. Daniel Kahneman praised the technique in Thinking, Fast and Slow as a simple way to push back against the overconfidence that settles over groups once they have made a decision.

Other ways to invert

Once you start looking, inversion shows up everywhere good organisations work.

Start from the end. At Amazon, teams proposing a new product have famously been expected to write the press release first, as if the product had already launched, along with answers to the questions customers would likely ask. Writing the announcement before building the thing forces you to say clearly why anyone should care. If you cannot write a compelling press release, you probably should not build the product.

Break it on purpose. Netflix built a tool called Chaos Monkey that randomly switches off parts of its own systems while they are running. It sounds reckless. It is actually inversion turned into software. Instead of hoping the system survives failures, you cause failures constantly, so the engineers have no choice but to build something that copes with them.

Study the crashes. In 1935, Boeing's new bomber, the Model 299, crashed during a demonstration flight in Ohio, killing two of its crew. The investigation found that the experienced pilot had forgotten to release a lock on the controls. The plane was not too dangerous to fly; it was too complicated to fly from memory. The response was simple: a checklist. Pilots went through a short list of steps before takeoff and landing. The aircraft went on to become the B-17, and the humble checklist spread through aviation and, much later, into hospital operating rooms. It is a list of the ways things go wrong, turned into a habit.

The checklist is a list of the ways things go wrong, turned into a habit.

Inverting your own life

You can do all of this on a single sheet of paper.

Pick something you care about: your health, your company, a friendship, your studies. Write at the top: How would I ruin this? Then be honest, even a little brutal. For a company, it might be hiring people you do not trust, ignoring cash, avoiding hard conversations with your co-founder. For your health, it might be sleeping five hours, skipping movement and eating whatever is closest.

Read the list back. Most people find that they are already doing at least one item on it.

That is the quiet power of the exercise. Advice about success can feel distant and abstract. A list of the ways you are currently making things worse is uncomfortably concrete, and that discomfort is what makes you change.

The limits of looking backwards

Inversion has a weakness, and it is worth being honest about.

It is brilliant at preventing disaster and much weaker at producing greatness. A company that avoids every mistake can still be boring. A life spent only avoiding the ways people fail can become small and fearful. Nobody builds anything remarkable just by not doing stupid things.

So inversion works best as a partner, not a replacement. Dream forwards, check backwards. Decide boldly where you want to go, then turn around and ask what would stop you getting there.

Munger, who died in 2023 just short of his hundredth birthday, practised this for most of a century. He was not a man without ambition. He just believed the surest way to reach a great destination was to know, very precisely, all the places he did not want to end up.

Most people spend their lives asking how to win. A few quietly ask how they might lose, and then simply refuse to.

Further reading

  • Poor Charlie's Almanack — Charlie Munger, edited by Peter D. Kaufman
  • How to Solve It — George Pólya
  • The Checklist Manifesto — Atul Gawande
  • Thinking, Fast and Slow — Daniel Kahneman

More from the shelf

N04 · Mind · 7 minThe Quiet ExponentThe most powerful force in your life feels like nothing for years, and then it feels like everything. N05 · Mind · 7 minWhere Your Hours GoInformation was never the scarce thing. Your attention is, and an entire industry is built to harvest it. M01 · Machines · 7 minIn Defense of FrictionWe spent decades removing effort from everything, and accidentally removed some of the meaning with it.

See the whole library →